Fraudster to get
Tenzing Norgay National Award for land Adventure
Mt Everest Expedition team Leader Naba Kumar Phukon of Assam says
Tenzing Norgay Award recipient in 2020- Narender Singh never summited Mt
Everest on May 20, 2016 .
The award in question?
Ever since the
Tenzing Norgay National Adventure Awards were announced last week, mountaineers
all over the country are up in arms about one of the recipients in the Land
Adventure category. The man in question is Narender Singh of Haryana who faked
his Everest Summit in 2016 by providing photoshopped images. He claimed he
climbed Everest on May 20th, 2016. However, his team leader Naba Kumar Phukon
of Assam has gone on record to say that Narendra Singh did not summit Mt
Everest in 2016. Speaking from Assam, Naba recounts the entire conversation
between him and Narender Singh, “On 19
th evening, Narender and I
were at South Col (Camp 4). Narender complained to me that he did not have
sufficient oxygen, I advised him to descend as without oxygen one cannot summit
Everest. I then left for my summit push and summited Everest on May 20th, 7:45
am. On my return I met climbers from Bengal police at South Col and asked them
about Narender. They mentioned that they met him mid-way between Camp 2 and 3.
I met him again on 21st May at Camp 2, he had developed frostbite.
When I left for basecamp he was still at camp 2. I reached Kathmandu on May 23rd,
received my certificate and came home.”
When asked about
Narender and his fake summit certificate he
says, “I got to know two days back when I read he is getting the Tenzing
Norgay Award. I wondered on what basis and I saw a report saying he has
summited Everest which is a total lie. I’m 100% sure that he did not summit, it
was just not possible, he did not have oxygen and he had developed frostbite''.
Naba and Narender
Singh was on the expedition with Nepali agency Seven Summits.
Another
Everester, Ramesh Roy, who summited the same year on May 21st, speaking to me
from Kolkata, also said Narender Singh did not summit Everest. “I and 3 other
mountaineers were resting in our tent at Summit Camp. Narender Singh was crying
in the next tent and when we asked what happened he told us that he could not
summit as he did not have enough Oxygen and hence returning back. I met him
again around 26th May, 2016 in Kathmandu and he showed me his certificate and
said see I have my summit certificate. I was shocked. It will be a disaster if
he is given the Tenzing Norgay National Award for Adventure.”
Lakhpa Sherpa from Nepal, who was part of the
rescue team on Everest in May 2016 season says, " in 2016, Narender Yadav
was not able to summit Mt Everest. I was in the rescue team that season and we
rescued him from Everest Balcony (8400 mts). He was not able to go ahead of the
balcony. I was shocked to see the Summit certificate in his hands. It's the
mistake of Nepal's operating company> So he should not be given such a
prestigious award. proper judgement should be done during the distribution of
such a paragon award otherwise it will be disrespectful to many good Indian
climbers.
In 2016, I had
exposed the Fake Summit of Mt Everest by the husband-wife duo Dilip and
Tarkeshwari Rathore, constables from Maharashtra Police (https://www.mid-day.com/articles/himalayan-con-probe-ordered-into-pune-couples-everest-record/17381162)
through this very newspaper. After relentless reporting for 14 months Nepal
Govt and Department of Tourism of Nepal (in-charge of Mt Everest expeditions
and giving certificates) cancelled their Summit certificates. They were
eventually expelled from the Police service.
While working on
the police constable investigation, I had come across Narender Singh’s case and
I tried to expose his fake summit as well. I could not expose him in 2016 only
because of lack of photo evidence and no first-hand eye witness accounts. Had I
exposed him then, today the mountaineering community in India would not be
disappointed.
(pics Attached).
The picture he posted on Social Media and the newspaper pictures are different
and clearly show they were morphed. One summit picture shows his face without
the oxygen mask and in the other picture he is seen sitting with his oxygen
mask, however, the mask has no oxygen pipe which clearly indicates that it is a
bad photoshop job. He is seen sitting beside another climber in the pictures
and the background is different in both. I tried to speak to him during my
investigation in 2016 but he refused to talk to me.
Nepal Press in
2016, did talk of his fake Everest summit based on his morphed summit photos
but did not take it to a conclusion by investigating or speaking to him or the
Nepalese agency Seven Summit and have his certificate cancelled.
Tenzing Norgay
Adventure Award was instituted in 1993 to celebrate and recognize excellence in
the field of adventure sports Land, Air, Sea and Lifetime achievement. Past
recipients of this award have been stalwarts like Bachinderi Pal, Chandraprabha
Aitwal, Wangchuk Sherpa, Premlata Agarwal, Brigadier Ashok Abbey, Palden
Giachho who in the 27 year history of the award have raised its prestige and
been an inspiration and standard of achievement in the sport.
It is shocking to
note on what basis Narender Singh is being given this award. He has no credible
mountaineering achievements. Is merely filling an application form and giving
basic details about climbs done in the last three years (2017, 2018 and 2019)
enough? Is showing certificates and some local newspaper articles about
climbing Mt Kilimanjaro and Mt Elbarus enough to win the Tenzing Norgay
Adventure Award?
Tensing
Norgay National Adventure Award – the highest award for a mountaineer in India was instituted in
1993 to celebrate and recognize excellence in the field of adventure sports
Land, Air, Sea and Lifetime achievement in these areas of sports. Past
recipients of this award have been stalwarts like Bachinderi Pal, Chandraprabha Aitwal,
Wangchuk Sherpa, Premlata Agarwal, Brigadier Ashok Abbey, Palden Giachho who in
the 27-year history of the award has raised its prestige and been an
inspiration and standard of achievement in the sport.
Even
the younger recipients of Award Nugshi and Tashi Mallik, Arunima Sinha, Anshu
Jamsenpa and all the others have furthered the course of the sport in their own
way and pushed their peers to strive for further and higher excellence.
I
wonder what the word ‘Excellence’ means now? What is the criteria of giving
such a highest award? Is it mere recommendations and filling a mere application
form which also has only the candidate to fill in some basic details and talk
about what climbs have you done in the last three years ( 2017, 2018 and 2019)
. Showing that you have certificates and some articles about yourself in local
newspapers about having climbed Mt Everest, Kilimanjaro-highest peak in Africa
and Elbarus -highest in Russia is enough to win a Tenzing Norgay Award?
Debabrata
Mukherjee, an Internationally Certified Mountain Guide and the oldest Indian to
Summit Mt Everest at the age of 52 in 2014 from the North says, “Faking Everest
seems to be a trend in India. Such a high honour cannot be given on climbing
just Kilimanjaro and Elbarus. It has to be given based merit and on overall
climbing skill, new route and technical difficulty and partly on development of
mountaineering in India. Before selecting, the credentials should be checked by
IMF as this is the highest mountaineering award in the country.
Padmashree
Premlata Agarawal, the first Indian woman to scale the seven highest continental peaks of
the world and a recipient of the Tenzing Norgay National Adventure Award in
2017 says, “An enquiry committee has to be put in place and they should
investigate this person. In my opinion IMF should look into the matter as it
concerns Indian mountaineering”.
There are so many
more accomplished climbers in India who have an exemplary climbing record to
their credit, including multiple 8000ers in the last 3 years. The very fact
that the selection criteria for such a high honour is so flimsy has left many
deserving climbers to steer clear of these awards. A humble community that has
always stayed away from the limelight has finally raised its voice against the
award going to a man with questionable mountaineering credentials.
Naba Kumar Phukon
from Assam has also written to tensing Norgay’s son, Jamling Norgay,
requesting him to look into the matter.
Several questions
arise with regard to the selection criterion, verification process and the
range of individual achievement required to receive the highest adventure sports
honour in the country. These questions may or may not get answered, however,
the collective outrage of the mountaineering community proves that no voice
resonating with truth can be silenced.
https://www.mid-day.com/articles/man-who-faked-summiting-mount-everest-to-be-awarded/22956228?ref=component_article_infinitescroll_1